All Products

Sorrel | Shaquanda's Hot Sauce

Discover the vibrant heat of Shaquanda's Sorrel Hot Sauce! This bold blend combines fresh strawberry...

Keith's Steak Sauce | Keith's

A new LIMITED EDITION not-too-hot sauce from Try Guys Keith Habersberger for steak & other stuff...

Smoked Serrano Squash Reaper X | Butterfly Bakery -C

Smoked Serrano Squash Reaper X from Butterfly Bakery is a craft hot sauce that brings a unique blend...

Honey Field Habanero | Butterfly Bakery of Vermont

Move over Tabasco (sorry - we went there), this is your new go-to breakfast hot sauce. It’s splashy,...

Secret Handshake Hot Sauce Duo Pack

Get both hot sauce flavors developed in partnership the guys at Santagato Studios (aka Secret Handsh...

Hot House Hot Sauce | Butterfly Bakery

Claire Georges started Butterfly Bakery as, well, a bakery before a surplus of local Vermont jalapen...

Secret Handshake Food Co Everything Bagel Hot Sauce 2-Pack

Everyone’s favorite bagel order, the Everything Bagel was invented sometime between 1973 and 1980 in...

Smoked Habanero & Peach | Smokin' Dragon -C

Smoked Habanero & Peach | Smokin' Dragon -C is a craft hot sauce that brings together the smoky ...

6 Months - Hot Ones Box

This 6-Month Hot Ones Box subscription delivers a curated selection of craft hot sauces from around ...

Garlic Delight | Microsaucerie -C

Garlic Delight from Microsaucerie -C is a craft hot sauce that brings a bold, garlic-forward flavor ...

Heatonist Tote Bag

These HEATONIST neon hot sauce totes have been tried and tested at our hot sauce tasting rooms and h...

1 Year - Hot Ones Box

This 1 Year - Hot Ones Box is a subscription option from Heatonist, the premier shop for craft hot s...